giovedì 19 novembre 2026

According to the Turin Court: special protection and the evidence of family life

According to the Turin Court: special protection requires a concrete examination of family life

The Ordinary Court of Turin, Ninth Civil Division, in judgment no. 6125 deposited on 4 December 2024 (case no. 21510/2023), examined an application for special protection by a Russian national who had settled in Italy with his wife. The decision is particularly instructive on the evidential role of family relationships and on the need to identify the legislation applicable at the time of the application.

The factual background

The applicant entered Italy in September 2022 on a multiple-entry tourist visa and lodged a special-protection application in December 2022. The Turin police rejected it in October 2023, following an adverse opinion by the Territorial Commission. The applicant challenged that decision. In the judicial proceedings, he produced evidence concerning the couple's accommodation, his wife's lawful stay for academic studies, her pregnancy, their economic circumstances and their life together in Turin.

What the Court decided

The Court allowed the claim and found that the statutory conditions for special protection had been met. It directed that the papers be transmitted to the competent Questura for the corresponding residence permit. The judgment did not rest on the fact of marriage alone. It assessed the lived reality of the relationship through documents including the tenancy agreement, residence documentation, the wife's renewed residence permit, pregnancy evidence, work documents and bank accounts.

The decisive legal concern was whether removal would infringe the applicant's right to respect for private and family life. The judges concluded that, given the family circumstances and ties established in Italy, the conditions were satisfied in this particular case.

The time-sensitive legal framework

The application had been made in December 2022. The Court therefore expressly applied the framework introduced by Decree-Law 130/2020, before the changes made by Decree-Law 20/2023. This distinction is indispensable for practice: the judgment must not be cited as though its statutory wording automatically governed every application filed today. Transitional provisions, the date of the application and the precise form of protection sought all matter.

Practical lessons for legal representatives

A well-prepared case should document the family relationship and its effective exercise in Italy, together with housing, income, residence history and any other relevant social ties. Where possible, organise the evidence chronologically and explain the concrete consequences of removal. Do not replace analysis with an unparticularised assertion of 'integration'. The administration's reasons for refusal also need to be addressed specifically.

The judgment illustrates an individual assessment under the applicable statutory framework, not a blanket exemption from immigration requirements. Families should obtain advice on the particular permit route, the competent authority and the procedural deadlines relevant to their own situation.

Judicial source: Ordinary Court of Turin, Ninth Civil Division, judgment no. 6125/2024, deposited 4 December 2024, case no. 21510/2023. Full decision.


Avv. Fabio Loscerbo
Lawyer admitted to practice before the Italian Court of Cassation
Registered in the Italian Chamber of Deputies' register of interest representatives in the field of immigration
Interest representative registered in the European Union Transparency Register under no. 280782895721-36 for migration and asylum
ORCID: 0009-0004-7030-0428
This article was prepared with the assistance of AI tools, under the author's direction, review and editorial responsibility.

Nessun commento:

Posta un commento

According to the Turin Court: special protection and the evidence of family life

According to the Turin Court: special protection requires a concrete examination of family life The Ordinary Court of Turin, Ninth Civil Div...