According to the Friuli-Venezia Giulia Administrative Court, a year outside the EU does not always justify automatic withdrawal of long-term residence
A European Union long-term resident permit provides greater stability than an ordinary residence permit, but it is not immune from withdrawal. One particularly important rule concerns prolonged absence from the territory of the European Union. Does an uninterrupted absence of more than twelve months necessarily mean losing that status, regardless of the reason? A judgment of the Italian Regional Administrative Court for Friuli-Venezia Giulia provides a concrete, carefully qualified answer. It also illustrates why medical records and an opportunity to make representations matter in proceedings before the Questura.
The judgment and the actual dispute
The decision is TAR Friuli-Venezia Giulia, Section I, judgment no. 381 of 13 September 2025. A foreign national challenged the decision of the Questura of Pordenone to withdraw his EU long-term resident permit and refuse to update it. According to the administration, he had been absent from the EU for more than twelve consecutive months, approximately between October 2017 and October 2019. The record also referred to a lengthy interruption of registration in the municipality's population register.
The applicant did not merely deny that time had passed. He argued, among other matters, that his absence had been connected to serious medical difficulties experienced in Tunisia and that the administration should have examined the supporting documents before depriving him of his long-term status. He also invoked his history of residence and integration in Italy. Those submissions were relevant to the legal question: whether the withdrawal mechanism could be applied without examining grave and documented reasons for the absence.
What Article 9 of the Immigration Act says
Article 9(7)(d) of Legislative Decree no. 286/1998 identifies an absence from EU territory for twelve consecutive months as a ground for withdrawing EU long-term resident status. Read in isolation, the wording may appear to create a purely automatic consequence. The court, however, considered the relationship between that provision and Article 9(6), which regulates the relevance of absences when the qualifying residence period is calculated and refers to serious and documented reasons, including health-related circumstances.
The judgment acknowledged that Italian administrative case law had not always been uniform. One approach treated the twelve-month period as an objective condition that left the administration no room to examine personal reasons. Another approach required a proper assessment of sufficiently grave and substantiated reasons for an extended absence. The Friuli-Venezia Giulia court adopted the second approach, following the reasoning of the Italian Council of State in judgment no. 10222/2024.
The point is not that every lengthy absence is excused. The point is that the Questura cannot necessarily treat the calendar as the only fact that matters when the individual has put forward relevant, documented grounds that call for assessment under the interpretation adopted by the court.
Why the Questura's decision was annulled
The decisive defect was not a finding that the claimant's medical problems automatically entitled him to retain the permit. Rather, the administration had explicitly taken the position that explanations for the prolonged absence did not need to be examined when applying Article 9(7)(d). For the court, that approach caused a failure of investigation and reasoning. The administration had not performed the assessment required by the legal interpretation accepted in the judgment.
The TAR therefore upheld the appeal and annulled the withdrawal decision. It directed the administration to reconsider the case and, in particular, to determine whether the medical documentation actually justified the period of absence exceeding twelve consecutive months. It did not itself decide whether the medical evidence was sufficient, nor did it order unconditional restoration of the permit regardless of further findings. Costs were compensated in view of the interpretative disagreement in the case law.
This distinction is critical in legal practice. Annulment for an inadequate investigation is not the same as a judicial declaration that all statutory requirements have been met. The administration must carry out a fresh and reasoned assessment, respecting the judgment.
Which documents should be assembled?
A person facing such a withdrawal should begin with a precise chronology, not with a general assertion of attachment to Italy. Useful materials may include the long-term residence card and earlier immigration decisions; a record of dates of departure, transit and return, supported by passports, tickets and other available records; medical certificates, hospital records, treatment appointments and evidence explaining why travel or return was not realistically possible; and any relevant certified translations. Medical documents should explain their dates and practical impact, not merely record the existence of a condition.
Evidence of family, work, accommodation and residence in Italy may also be relevant to the broader assessment. Such evidence does not replace proof of the reason for the extended absence. If the issue first emerges in a request to update an old-format card, it is especially important to check whether the Questura has opened a separate withdrawal procedure and what communication has actually been served.
How to respond to the administrative procedure
First, obtain a copy of the contested decision and, where necessary, access to the administrative file. It matters whether the administration has correctly identified the relevant dates, the geographical scope of the absence and the legal basis for withdrawal. A period outside Italy is not automatically identical to a period outside the entire EU.
Second, submit a structured response to any notice of proposed refusal or withdrawal, addressing Article 9 and attaching documents on the reasons for absence. Any administrative submission should be dated, verifiable and specific: the authority needs to know exactly which periods are disputed and which documents explain them.
Third, if a withdrawal has been adopted, obtain individual advice promptly on judicial remedies and applicable time limits. A decision such as TAR Friuli-Venezia Giulia no. 381/2025 can support an argument that reasons were unlawfully ignored, but it is not a guarantee of success in a different case. The competent judge, applicable deadline and possible interim protection depend on the challenged act and the particular procedural position.
What the ruling does not establish
There is no universal medical exception allowing an EU long-term resident to remain indefinitely abroad while preserving status. Serious reasons must be documented and evaluated in their factual context. Nor does this ruling mean that an ordinary work permit issued at a different time necessarily cures every defect affecting long-term residence. Different types of permits, their prerequisites and the consequences of withdrawal must be examined separately.
It is equally important not to confuse the rule about withdrawal after twelve consecutive months outside the EU with the rules about counting absences when initially qualifying for long-term residence. The court connected the provisions for purposes of interpretation; it did not erase the statutory distinction between them.
The practical lesson
The judicial protection illustrated by this case is protection against a mechanical administrative decision where relevant facts were left unexamined. Someone who can explain a prolonged absence should make that explanation early, with contemporaneous supporting documents. A lawyer considering an appeal should identify the precise omission in the investigation, rather than simply asking the TAR to substitute its own assessment for that of the Questura. In immigration administration, accurate evidence and reasons remain just as important as the number of days recorded on a passport.
Judicial source: Tribunale Amministrativo Regionale per il Friuli-Venezia Giulia, Section I, judgment 13 September 2025, no. 381; full published text: EIUS – judgment no. 381/2025. Legal reference: Article 9(6) and (7)(d), Legislative Decree no. 286/1998. The article is a reasoned explanation of the judgment, not individualized legal advice.
Avv. Fabio Loscerbo
Lawyer qualified to practise before the Italian Court of Cassation
Registered in the Italian Chamber of Deputies' Register of Interest Representatives in the field of Immigration
Lobbyist registered in the Transparency Register of the European Union, no. 280782895721-36, in the field of Migration and Asylum
ORCID: 0009-0004-7030-0428
Article prepared with the assistance of AI tools, under the author's direction, review and editorial responsibility.
Nessun commento:
Posta un commento