According to the Liguria Administrative Court, an extra residence-permit application cannot by itself cancel a valid work authorisation under Italy's quota system
Italy's procedure for hiring a worker from abroad involves several administrative steps, sometimes handled by different offices. An employer may obtain a nulla osta al lavoro, the worker may enter Italy with a visa, and the residence-permit procedure may then involve both the Single Immigration Desk (Sportello Unico per l'Immigrazione) and the police headquarters (Questura). What happens if a worker, seeking to regularise the position, submits an additional permit application to the Questura before the Single Immigration Desk's procedure has formally ended?
The Regional Administrative Court for Liguria, First Section, addressed that precise issue in judgment no. 1083 of 28 September 2026. Its answer is important for employers, workers and legal representatives: an unnecessary or incorrectly submitted parallel application is not, in itself, a statutory ground for withdrawing an existing work authorisation.
The facts: entry through the quota procedure, followed by a second application
The applicant had entered Italy after a work authorisation was granted through the immigration quota scheme, commonly known as the decreto flussi. She subsequently submitted an application to the Questura of Savona for a residence permit for employment, using the assistance of a tax-assistance centre.
On 8 July 2025, the Prefecture of Savona notified her of a proposed withdrawal of the work authorisation. The reason given was not an adverse finding concerning the employer, a disqualifying criminal record or a newly discovered statutory impediment. Instead, the Prefecture objected to the fact that the worker had applied to the Questura before the process at the Single Immigration Desk had been completed. The Prefecture then withdrew the authorisation on 19 July 2025.
The worker challenged the withdrawal, alleging inadequate investigation and reasons, factual errors and incorrect application of immigration legislation. The court had already suspended the effects of the contested measure as an interim step during the proceedings.
The governing provisions and the court's reasoning
Article 22 of Legislative Decree no. 286/1998 regulates the entry of foreign workers for employed work and the role of the Single Immigration Desk. It also identifies circumstances in which work authorisation and connected documents may be withdrawn following the later discovery of legally relevant obstacles. The judgment additionally examined Article 42 of Decree-Law no. 73/2022, which had introduced specific provisions concerning authorisations and subsequent checks.
The court found that neither framework provided for withdrawal merely because the worker had lodged an additional residence-permit request with another office before completion of the original process. The Prefecture had treated a procedural irregularity as if it were an express statutory ground for withdrawing a substantive authorisation.
The judges described the second application as erroneous and superfluous, but rejected the inference that it should automatically prejudice the correctly initiated procedure. They also recalled a general administrative-law principle: where an authority receives an application outside its competence, the appropriate response is ordinarily to refer it to the competent authority, inform the applicant and cooperate as required, rather than invent an adverse consequence unsupported by law.
What the court ordered—and what it did not order
The TAR allowed the claim and annulled the Prefecture's withdrawal decision. The administration was ordered to reimburse the costs of the litigation, assessed at EUR 1,500 plus statutory accessories and the court fee where paid.
The judgment did not itself issue a residence permit, nor did it state that every worker who makes an incorrect application must automatically be granted a permit. It addressed the legality of one specific withdrawal ground: the submission of a parallel and unnecessary request to the Questura. Other requirements and any genuinely existing statutory obstacles must still be assessed under the applicable legislation.
Why a later positive administrative development did not end the litigation
During the proceedings the administration informed the court that, on 4 June 2026, the Questura had given a favourable opinion on the employer's application and that a further appointment would be arranged. The Prefecture therefore argued that the dispute had effectively been resolved.
The TAR disagreed. A favourable procedural indication did not show that the contested withdrawal had actually been set aside, or that the worker had received the practical legal protection requested. A mere expectation of further administrative action could not be treated as complete satisfaction of the claimant's interests. Because the withdrawal remained in place and no final resolution was established, the court examined the merits and annulled the measure.
This part of the ruling has an independent lesson for litigation strategy: a letter promising an appointment or referring to a favourable opinion should not automatically be mistaken for a formal withdrawal of the challenged act. Lawyers must distinguish an administrative assurance from an operative decision that actually changes the client's legal position.
Practical steps for workers and employers
Map the entire procedure. Keep separate records of the work authorisation, entry visa, arrival date, Single Immigration Desk appointments, employment documents, applications submitted to the Questura and any associated receipts. A timeline can reveal whether two applications were being processed in parallel and why.
Preserve the precise grounds for any proposed withdrawal. A notice of intended withdrawal and the final decision should be read closely. The critical question is not whether the administration considers an application unnecessary, but whether the particular legal consequence it proposes has a statutory basis.
Respond before a final negative decision when possible. Where an adverse administrative notice allows observations, provide a concise explanation of why the extra filing occurred, what the main procedure's status is and which documents establish continued compliance. Where necessary, ask the offices to coordinate or transfer documents. This approach does not excuse genuinely false statements, missing requirements or statutory impediments.
Do not assume that a favourable opinion closes a dispute. Request written confirmation of the operative decision, the removal of the negative measure and any further steps required from the worker or employer. If litigation is pending, assess whether the material interest has truly been satisfied.
Obtain tailored advice before filing a judicial challenge. The applicable forum, deadlines, interim relief and the relationship between the authorisation and the residence-permit application must be checked against the precise acts issued. A worker should not deliberately submit duplicate applications as a supposed shortcut; the judgment protects against an unsupported sanction, not against all procedural mistakes.
A broader principle for immigration administration
Administrative legality is particularly important in procedures divided among the Prefecture, Single Immigration Desk and Questura. An office must act within the powers assigned to it and rely on legally defined grounds when withdrawing an authorisation. Coordination problems and unnecessary filings should be addressed with appropriate procedural measures, rather than automatically converted into substantive disqualifications.
The decision is not a promise that the quota procedure will succeed in every case. It is a carefully bounded ruling that strengthens the distinction between an application made through the wrong channel and a genuine legal obstacle to work-based immigration. That distinction is essential both to sound administration and to effective judicial review.
Verified judgment: TAR Liguria, Sezione I, judgment 28 September 2026, no. 1083 (President Caruso; reporting judge Pistilli). Full Italian text of the judgment. Principal legislation discussed: Legislative Decree no. 286/1998, Article 22; Decree-Law no. 73/2022, Article 42; Law no. 241/1990 on administrative procedure.
Avv. Fabio Loscerbo
Lawyer authorised to practise before the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation
Registered in the Chamber of Deputies' Register of Interest Representatives in the field of Immigration
Lobbyist registered in the European Union Transparency Register, no. 280782895721-36, in the field of Migration and Asylum
ORCID: 0009-0004-7030-0428
This article was prepared with the assistance of AI tools, under the author's direction, review and editorial responsibility.
Nessun commento:
Posta un commento